Reviews
Other
COME AND SEE
This shattering, impressionistic Russian epic can be viewed as a hallucinatory depiction of the horrors of war, an unforgiving expose of Nazi atrocities that makes SCHINDLER’S LIST look like LASSIE COME HOME, or as a straightforward descent into madness. COME AND SEE is a visionary masterpiece in any interpretation, a film from which no viewer will emerge unchanged.
The Package
COME AND SEE (IDI I SMOTRI; 1985), the undoubted masterwork of filmmaker
Elem Klimov, was initially conceived and scripted in the mid-seventies,
following the completion of Klimov’s Rasputin biopic
AGONY. COME AND SEE,
originally titled KILL HITLER!, was based on a novella, THE KHATYN STORY by Ales
Adamovich, which was inspired by its author’s own WWII experiences. Klimov
further drew upon his own childhood memories of the war in crafting the script.
The Russian film industry being the lumbering,
inefficient machine it was in those pre-Glasnost days, it took seven years for
COME AND SEE to begin production (while AGONY remained shelved until the
mid-eighties). In the interim Klimov’s wife, filmmaker Larissa Shepitko, whose
masterful WWII drama ASCENT (1976) can be seen as a sort of dry run for COME AND
SEE, was killed in a car accident. Her widow’s grief haunts the latter film,
which was to be Klimov’s last. He was set to direct an adaptation of Mikhail
Bulgakov’s satiric classic THE MASTER AND MARGARITA, which never came to pass (a
shame, as that’s a film I’d like to see!). Reportedly, in the wake of
COME AND SEE, Klimov “lost interest” in making films. He died in 2003, shortly
after COME AND SEE’S long-awaited debut on DVD in the US.
The Story
Florya is a naïve young boy living with his mother and two younger sisters
in the Soviet region of Byelorussia sometime in the late thirties. One day some
soldiers show up, recruiting able-bodied young men to fight the invading Nazis;
Florya eagerly joins the cause, much to the consternation of his mother.
Unfortunately, once he arrives at the Partisan base camp, Florya finds his
heroic dreams shattered as he’s branded “the new kid” and forced to do odd jobs
around the camp. Worst of all, he’s left behind to look after things when it
comes time for the company to march off to battle. There is compensation,
however, in the form of Glascha, an alluring peasant girl who’s been sleeping
with the company’s leader. She turns her attentions to Florya, but their
relationship is interrupted by a paratroop attack during which Florya is briefly
struck deaf.
Florya decides to take Glascha back to his mother’s home, but finds it and
the surrounding town strangely deserted. He figures the townspeople must be on
a nearby island, but Glascha spots a mass of dead bodies stacked against the
side of a house and realizes the truth: that the invading Nazis have massacred
everybody in the town. After a nightmarish slog through a muddy swamp, Florya
is forced to face the painful truth of the killings of all his friends and
family, and adjust to a new reality of horror and sudden death.
From there Florya is plunged deeper into wartime mayhem, taking off on a
desperate trek with three surviving townspeople, all of whom are killed by enemy
fire. Eventually Florya finds himself trapped in a Nazi-occupied Bylorussian
town as its citizens are forced into a church, which the Nazis then burn to the
ground. In the conflagration Florya’s hair turns grey and his face becomes
wrinkled. Glascha is also drawn into the mayhem, and ends up a catatonic
vegetable after being gang raped. The partisan forces manage to ambush the Nazi
invaders and kill them all, but the horror of all he’s experienced will scar
Florya forever.
The Direction
As he proved in his brilliant films FAREWELL and AGONY, Elem Klimov was
unsurpassed in his ability to create nightmarish imagery. He demonstrates that
talent again and again in COME AND SEE, which contains a wealth of profoundly
unsettling, impossible to forget scenes, from a close-up a dying cow’s eye
moving back and forth in its socket to the panoramic climax, with hundreds of
extras forcibly marched to their death, certainly one of the most traumatizing
sequences in cinema history. However, Klimov also manages to conjure moments of
poetic beauty, such as the strangely elegiac sight of young Glascha dancing in
the rain or the protagonist’s final majestic march through a vast forest.
Equally impressive is Klimov’s use of sound, particularly in the bit where the
protagonist is deafened by artillery fire, conveyed via a haunting electronic
buzz. Also, after experiencing this film I guarantee you’ll never be able to
listen to the drone of a biplane in quite the same way.
The lead performance of 13-year-old Alexei Kravchenko is a large part of
what makes the film so effective. His work here is among the most powerful
pre-pubescent emoting I’ve witnessed, managing to convey a profound and
decidedly unchildlike sense of a person at the end of his emotional rope,
presented with such intensity that the filmmakers were apparently worried the
young Kravchenko might literally go mad; for this reason, much of his
performance was apparently achieved under hypnosis. The climactic close-ups of
the actor’s prematurely wrinkled, grief-stricken face are among the film’s most
powerful images.
One thing that puzzles me are the statements of Klimov and others who
worked on the film, all of whom constantly reiterate the director’s apparent
dictum that everything in the film be as naturalistic as possible. Certainly
that tendency seems to have been rigorously followed in the production design,
but otherwise this one of the most heavily stylized movies I’ve seen. Indeed,
I’d venture to call COME AND SEE one of the great impressionistic films ever, as
mind bending as anything by Jodorowski and
Arrabal. The film is chock full of
bizarre scenes, such as the construction of a Hitler scarecrow by a soldier
affixing mud to a skull, or the protagonist digging a gun out of the ground in
blatantly sexual fashion. There are even moments of outright surrealism, such
as a crawl through a muddy bog that in the next scene becomes a lake. And let’s
not forget Klimov’s most audacious sequence, a newsreel montage depicting the
rise of the Third Reich in reverse chronology. The cumulative effect is one of
profound horror of a depth few other films have been able to approach, much less
match.
Vital Statistics
COME AND SEE (IDI I SMOTRI)
Byelorusfilm/Mosfilm Studios
Director: Elem Klimov
Screenplay: Elem Klimov, Ales Adamovich
(Based on a novel by Ales Adamovich)
Cinematography: Alexei Rodionov
Editing: V. Velova
Cast: Alexei Kravchenko, Olga Mironova, Lubomiras Lauciavicius, Vladas Bagdonas,
Juris Lumiste, Víktor Lorents, Kazizmir Rabetsky, Yevgeni Tilicheyev, Akeksandr
Berda, Igor Gnevashev, Vasili Domrachyov